Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

Cardano Founder Pushes Back on Claim That Midnight Isn’t Built on Cardano

Charles Hoskinson responds to Dave’s argument that Midnight’s independent ledger determines how its relationship with Cardano should be described.

- Advertisement -

Charles Hoskinson pushed back on November 15 after a Cardano community member argued that Midnight runs its own blockchain and therefore should not be described as “built on Cardano.”

The exchange turned on what those three words mean. Dave, posting as @ItsDave_ADA, was talking about which network processes Midnight transactions. Hoskinson was talking about what Cardano’s partner-chain model allows developers to build.

“The entire purpose of Cardano was to enable things like Midnight to be built,” Hoskinson wrote. He described the project as the result of ten years spent pursuing that model. His response echoed his earlier argument that Midnight is what Cardano was built for.

- Advertisement -

 

Line Between Midnight and Cardano

Dave’s November 14 comment acknowledged that Midnight integrates with Cardano. His objection concerned where the software runs.

He argued that Midnight has its own consensus, ledger and settlement layer, making it different from an application whose smart contracts execute directly on Cardano.

Midnight’s developer documentation supports that distinction. Midnight nodes process privacy-preserving smart contract transactions, verify proofs and maintain the network’s own ledger.

A developer running a contract on Midnight submits it to that network. Midnight even has its own upgrade schedule. On November 6, its mainnet moved from ledger version 8 to version 9.

Another participant, @seehereandnow, responded that the relationship benefits both networks and described Dave’s account as one-sided. Dave maintained that he was making a technical point, while allowing that the original excerpt might have referred to something else.

The disagreement then shifted from where Midnight transactions execute to what Cardano contributed to Midnight’s launch.

Why the Glacier Drop and NIGHT Changed the Argument

Angry Crypto Show asked which technology the Glacier Drop used, where NIGHT was issued and where its supply resided. The account answered “Cardano” and argued that bringing users into Cardano’s ecosystem had value of its own.

The first two questions have concrete answers. Midnight launched NIGHT as a native token on Cardano. Its distribution also used Hydra, Cardano’s layer-two scaling technology, to handle activity while limiting congestion on the base chain.

According to Midnight, participants claimed more than 3.5 billion NIGHT in the Glacier Drop phase alone. That gave Cardano a role in distributing the token even to people who qualified through other blockchain ecosystems.

The claim that 100% of NIGHT sits on Cardano goes further. Midnight documents a total supply of 24 billion NIGHT and confirms the token’s Cardano launch.

Establishing where every token resides at a later date would also require accounting for transfers between networks. Midnight’s November software release added a bridge component for transfers from Cardano to Midnight.

What Hoskinson Meant by Cardano’s Purpose

Hoskinson quoted Dave’s final reply, which repeated that Midnight was not built on Cardano. He treated that insistence as an example of the attitude he had criticized.

From his perspective, Cardano helped deliver the infrastructure for a specialized network, and Midnight’s ability to operate its own ledger is consistent with that goal. He had made a related point when discussing Cardano’s completed roadmap and the ecosystem’s next phase.

Midnight’s own documentation supplies the clearest description: Midnight operates its own blockchain and integrates with Cardano as a partner chain. Someone redeeming NIGHT through the Cardano distribution and someone executing a private contract on Midnight are using different parts of that architecture.

Dave explained the second activity. Angry Crypto Show pointed to the first. Hoskinson’s broader claim was that enabling both was part of Cardano’s purpose.

- Advertisement -
Albert Brown
Albert Brownhttps://thecryptobasic.com/
Albert Brown is a cryptocurrency investor and journalist who has been in the nascent space since 2017. His love and passion for technological innovations made him delve deeper into the world of blockchain and cryptocurrencies. As a journalist, Brown has written on several crypto-related topics that have been referenced by popular industry players like Tyler Winklevoss, Binance CZ, etc.

Tokenized Stocks